I had a few meetings with advisors today, and I'm feeling a little raw. The meetings went as well as they could, but I was urged to get off my ass and do some work for once, and nobody ever likes hearing that.
The good news is that I am doing work. the bad news is that I need to do more. lots more.
A few months ago I emailed a copy of a manuscript off to a professor to get her comments so I could submit it to a journal. We finally met today and she was kind but clear- it's not ready. In fact, it's nowhere near ready. Her words: "It seemed like a very good student paper."
Ouch. I mean, yes- it did start out as a student paper, but it's been revised several times since and it needs to get sent off already. Nobody likes being told they are amateur. Even when they are. the problem is that the paper is about a process, and it's about my process in particular. All that personal writing I do here was employed in that paper, and since it was about MY process, I wrote it in first person. I don't think academic writing as a whole is much improved by the use of third person narrative, in fact it lends to a false sense of objectivity that isn't truly possible in writing. So I wrote my story using my own voice, which given the circumstances makes the entire piece more readable. I don't see anything wrong with that. But I've already had two comments that suggest that the paper is not publishable as a first person piece, because some reviewers may be offended by the assertion that my personality and process is interesting and worth learning from. I still stand by the belief that science is subjective, and we should stop using these screens to try to obscure this fact.
I'm just ahead of my time. I was also told that a new and novice researcher can't get away with writing in the first person- this is a tool only allowed senior authorities. And there is little that will irritate me more than being told I'm not allowed to write a certain way because I'm not part of the old school. (This is the same old school that won't write in first person in the first place, so I don't see why it should even be an issue!)
The other meeting was the one where my advisor told me to get my freaking thesis published already and be done with it. C'mon, already! It's been three years, for fuck's sake. Well, she didn't say it quite like that, but you get the jist of it. That's when I broke it to her that I can't submit the damn manuscript until I get approval from the tribes I sampled from. Oops- she didn't like that a whole lot. doh!
It's going to be a long summer.
and jasmine is still missing.